Asaf Bartov (ijon) wrote,
Asaf Bartov

  • Mood:
  • Music:

A random browse through my mailbox yielded this pearl:

Some years ago, I asked my friend ygurvitz, a trained historian, a question. Uncharacteristically, he fell silent for a long time, and finally said "let me think about it." Some weeks later, he wrote to me:
A few weeks back, you asked me to name three periods in history, which can be defined as "happy". In the limited scope of Western history, I am afraid I cannot find three such periods. Many are the (court) historians who would describe the period of such-and-such ruler (oftentimes their patron) as the happiest epochs of humanity; often such lies can easily be discerned for what they are, sometimes it's difficult, but generally historians -- up to the present, and the Internet may yet play a significant part in changing that -- speak for those who have the time and the leisure to write, and appreciate, history, namely, the ruling classes; and such classes rarely enjoy life without the toil, sweat and all too often tears of an oppressed populace.

I cannot provide you with three examples; even the golden period of the "enlightened emperors", namely Nerva, Trajan, Hadrian, Antoninus Pius and Marcus Aurelius (98-180 AD) is described from the point of view of the rulers; and we can be sure that this may not be considered a "golden period" by Jews and Christians, for example. The one example I *am* capable of providing is Athens at its glory - namely, between the years 490 and 404 BCE. And while this period is unsurpassed in its vitality, we must remember that the Athenians had slaves, too. Those slaves were not the oppressed, terrorized and victimized Helots of Sparta - and, indeed, of all slave-holding societies, Athens is the only one that never seemed afraid of a slaves' revolt - but were considered parts of the household, living and eating with the free men; yet slaves they were, and though their lot was good - and many were freed, and granted citizenship - they must have remembered past lives of happiness.

So, once again, I return to Hobbes' (or is it Gibbon's?) claim that history is "a list of humankind's misfortunes, atrocities and stupidity". I cannot point to a golden age; I doubt, given what we now know of human nature, that it could ever have existed - or that it could exist in the future. To paraphrase Cicero, we do not live in Plato's republic, bur among the ruins of Stalin.


  • Shah of Shahs / Ryszard Kapuściński

    Exactly 38 years ago, Khomeini returned to Iran from his exile in France, and set in motion the Islamic Revolution of Iran. A little over a year…

  • On Immigrants

    Speaking of immigrants, Sir Ian McKellen would like to offer this passage, from the Elizabethan play Sir Thomas More: GEORGE. Marry, the removing…

  • Goodreads is fun; Dickens; Mortimer

    I've been pretty indifferent to most of the recent social-network sites, but I'm really enjoying I'm a pretty busy reader, with a…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.